Sod vs. Seed: Why Sod is Better Than Seeding & Hydroseeding (2024)

If you’re reading this, then it’s likely you have a new lawn or you’re trying to improve the lawn you have. You could also be a landscaper, grounds manager, or golf course owner, or you just want your lawn to look better than your neighbor’s lawn! You have likely been presented with the age-old decision: sod or seed?

For A Better Looking Lawn with Fewer Weeds, Choose Sod Over Seed

There’s one common reason why people choose to plant grass seed instead of laying sod and that reason is cost. Sod may cost more initially when compared to seeding. However, sod may be the perfect option for you if you’re looking to save time, effort, and reduce maintenance costs down the road. Below, we outline the benefits of sod over grass seed. Keep reading to learn more.

Sod is one of the most environmentally responsible materials you can add to your home or business. Healthy turfgrass controls erosion, decreases runoff, restores soil quality, purifies air and groundwater, and converts carbon dioxide into oxygen. It also reduces dust and noise, adds visual appeal, and increases property values.

Benefits of Sod Over Seed

We know you take pride in how your lawn looks, and so do we. Below we’ll share the top five advantages of sod, and why it’s the best choice if you want a beautiful, lush lawn, in a day. So continue reading to find out how to make your neighbors green with envy (pun intended!).

1. Sod provides you with instant results

Many newly seeded lawns need up to 10 to 12 weeks before they’re ready for even light foot traffic. Weather also influences growing speeds. With sod, you don’t have to wait and spend years to nurture a newly seeded lawn to grow, while battling weeds and washouts. Enjoy your lush, green lawn immediately.

When sod is first installed, it’s not ready for normal lawn traffic, but it instantly looks like a finished lawn. Once sod roots establish, it’s ready for normal lawn traffic, including entertaining, play, and pets.

Another advantage to sod is that it can be installed anytime during the growing season, as long as the ground is not frozen, and you have sufficient water for establishment and maintenance. A newly seeded lawn needs one full growing season before it’s dense, mature, and established well enough to withstand vigorous lawn traffic. It also faces many more variables and risks, such as germination rate, rain wash-outs and weed competition.

2. Sod saves you time and effort

Seeding a lawn requires greater initial maintenance. For seeds to establish well, they must be sown during peak growth times for the grass involved. The optimum time in our area is August to mid-September. Watering is also critical during seed establishment. Careful monitoring and attention are essential in this phase.

Sod, however, is a mature, dense, weed-free and instant lawn. It will generally root in 2-3 weeks after it’s installed, with proper care. Seed or hydroseed will need your full attention for over a year to get similar results—provided it doesn’t wash out with the first rainstorm.

3. Sod offsets maintenance costs & saves you money

Did you know that failed seed or weak grass is susceptible to insects, weeds and disease? As you can probably guess, if this happens with your new lawn, not only will it take more of your time and effort to fix or start over, but this also leads to higher or unexpected maintenance costs.

Herbicides, insecticides, and fungicides cost money. Many novices over-apply these products while they learn through trial and error how to grow their lawns. We have been farming sod for over 30 years—leaving these initial applications to experienced growers saves you a fortune.

4. Sod saves frustrating weeds, stops washouts, and controls mud

When growing grass, weather affects the outcome of everything you do. Have you ever seen a turquoise trail in the street from a hydroseeded lawn? Sod helps control erosion the minute it is laid. If you have children or pets, sod keeps the mud and mess from being tracked inside.

Until roots establish, seed and soil can wash away or pool in heavy rains and void your efforts. On slopes or areas with erosion problems, sod works as a blanket to help hold soil in place from the start. Leaving bare, wet soil to sprout grass seed can also invite irritating weeds, which will hinder your growing progress. Sod notoriously provides a natural weed barrier, while some varieties of sod, such as Scott’s ProVista, are carefully manufactured to be weed-resistent.

5. Sod looks better & stays healthy

At Saratoga Sod, we start with the best plant genetics, care for, and maintain our sod for 18 to 24 months before harvesting. This guarantees beautiful, healthy sod that is professionally and expertly tended for an award-worthy lawn.

Sod is one of the most environmentally responsible materials you can add to your home or business. Healthy turfgrass controls erosion, decreases runoff, restores soil quality, purifies air and groundwater, and converts carbon dioxide into oxygen. It also reduces dust and noise, adds visual appeal, and increases property values.

For more questions about sod versus seed, get in touch with an expert here.

Sod vs. Seed: Why Sod is Better Than Seeding & Hydroseeding (2024)

FAQs

Sod vs. Seed: Why Sod is Better Than Seeding & Hydroseeding? ›

Sod looks better & stays healthy

Is sod better than hydroseed? ›

If there's a competition between hydroseed and sod, give sod the trophy — sod almost always wins. It's instant lawn that looks great right away. Its roots are already developed and ready to take root in your soil.

What are the downsides of hydroseeding? ›

Disadvantages of Hydroseeding

Overall, hydroseeding is a very cost-effective option, considering the higher germination rate than conventional seeding methods. However, like traditional seeding, the time of year hydroseed can be installed is limited, and it also has moderate to high water needs.

How much cheaper is hydroseed than sod? ›

The price of hydroseeding vs. sod is generally 1:3 – around 15 cents per square foot of hydroseeding vs. 45 cents per square foot for sod.

What are the pros and cons of sod? ›

Sod – Though initially sod may appear weed free, it is not always guaranteed to be weed free, seed is. Sod is a great alternative for sloped areas or erosion-prone areas where seed would struggle to survive. On the down side, only certain types of grass are grown for sodding so your choices are limited.

Why is sod better than seed? ›

If you have children or pets, sod keeps the mud and mess from being tracked inside. Until roots establish, seed and soil can wash away or pool in heavy rains and void your efforts. On slopes or areas with erosion problems, sod works as a blanket to help hold soil in place from the start.

Is it cheaper to reseed or sod? ›

The average cost of sod installation is around $2,000, or between $1.20 and $2.85 per square foot. On the other hand, the average cost to seed a lawn is a bit more budget-friendly at $450 to $1,700, or about $0.10 to $0.20 per square foot.

Why does hydroseed fail? ›

There is a high rate of failure associated with hydroseeding due to inadequate preparation and the soil environment. It is possible for the earth to get severely compacted on building sites. When this takes place, it becomes more challenging for water, air, and roots to penetrate the soil.

Will heavy rain ruin my hydroseed? ›

Unfortunately, hydroseed is not exempt from soil erosion. While the new seeds need to be constantly watered for the first few weeks after planting, heavy rain can cause issues. If heavy rains fall before your seeds have a chance to grow roots, they can be easily displaced.

Do you get weeds with hydroseeding? ›

Any spring lawn installation will flush with weeds.

It's not so much an issue of quality hydroseed or even quality loam. All screened loam will have millions of weed seeds that lay dormant.

How much does it cost to hydroseed 1/2 acre? ›

Hydroseeding cost estimator by lawn size
Yard sizeAverage overall cost
¼ acre (10,890 sq. ft.)$600 – $2,100
½ acre (21,780 sq. ft.)$1,300 – $4,300
¾ acre (32,670 sq. ft.)$1,900 – $6,500
1 acre (43,560 sq. ft.)$2,600 – $8,700
2 more rows
Feb 22, 2024

How much will 500 gallons of hydroseed cover? ›

6,600 sq. ft.

Does hydroseed grow faster than seed? ›

A: Yes, hydroseed grows faster than dry grass seed because the slurry helps to enhance growth. Seed germination usually occurs within one week and by three or four weeks of grass growth, it is visible and ready to be mowed.

Is sod a waste of money? ›

Sod is hardy and grows well when properly installed, so your chances of lawn failure are minimal. Sod is also weed-free and quick to use. Sod can be prohibitively expensive. If the area where turf is needed is large, cost is a real issue.

Why can't you walk on new sod? ›

The reason for this is that if you step on the sod before the roots have taken to the soil, you disturb the delicate roots. Any mild disturbance will prevent the roots from winding down into the soil and allowing the sod to take hold.

What to know before buying sod? ›

When you're purchasing sod online take the time to know exactly where your sod comes from, and how quickly it arrives and will be installed after being cut on the farm. The sooner your fresh sod goes from farm to your soil, the better, so it doesn't dry out. The same day is best.

What is the best material to put over grass seed? ›

Mulch Options to Cover Grass Seed

Common options include straw, mushroom compost and peat moss.

Should I get new sod or overseed? ›

As a general rule of thumb, if your lawn is over 50% weeds it might be best to renovate your lawn and start over with new sod. If your lawn is less than 50% weeds, putting in the effort to restore your lawn by overseeding may be worthwhile.

Can you hydroseed over dead sod? ›

We do not recommend hydroseeding over an existing lawn. The best practice is to either start over from scratch by completely redoing the lawn, or implement a process called “overseeding.” Overseeding is done with a power rake (you can rent one from a hardware store) and then broadcasting seed.

How much does it cost to hydroseed 10,000 square feet? ›

Hydroseeding Cost by Square Foot
Yard Size, Square FeetAverage Cost
3,000$180–$600*
5,000$300–$1,000
7,500$450–$1,500
10,000$600–$2,000
2 more rows
May 5, 2024

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nicola Considine CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 6546

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nicola Considine CPA

Birthday: 1993-02-26

Address: 3809 Clinton Inlet, East Aleisha, UT 46318-2392

Phone: +2681424145499

Job: Government Technician

Hobby: Calligraphy, Lego building, Worldbuilding, Shooting, Bird watching, Shopping, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Nicola Considine CPA, I am a determined, witty, powerful, brainy, open, smiling, proud person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.